Why Is It So Hard to Lose Weight? How the Food Environment Works Against You
A big reason losing weight is hard is that the food around you is built to be overeaten. Ultra-processed food is inexpensive, everywhere and designed to taste great. In a controlled trial, people ate about 500 more calories a day on an ultra-processed diet than on a whole food one. You need a plan for your environment.
Is ultra-processed food really that different?
Yes. In an NIH study, adults lived in a lab for four weeks and spent two weeks on an ultra-processed diet and two weeks on a minimally processed diet, matched for calories, sugar, fat, fiber and salt on offer. They could eat as much as they wanted. On the ultra-processed diet they ate about 508 more calories a day and gained weight. On the whole food diet they lost weight (Hall et al., 2019).
Eating more of these foods is also linked with higher risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, depression and early death (Lane et al., 2024).
Why are these foods so easy to overeat?
- They combine sugar, fat and salt in ways that rarely occur in whole foods.
- They are soft and fast to eat, so you eat a lot before fullness kicks in.
- They are low in fiber and protein, the two things that keep you full.
- They are inexpensive, heavily marketed and available everywhere, all day.
Food companies have every reason to make products people buy again. That is business. It does not mean you are powerless.
Is obesity only about willpower?
No. The NIDDK lists many factors that affect weight: food and activity habits, where you live and work, sleep, stress, genes, medical conditions and some medications. Blaming people does not help them. Changing what is around them does.
An older version of this post claimed government health agencies are run to protect food company profits. I removed that because I cannot back it up. What I can say is that you should judge food by what is in it, not by health claims on the box.
How do I fight back against the food environment?
This is what works for my clients:
- Make whole foods the default. Lean meat, fish, eggs, beans, potatoes, rice, fruit and vegetables.
- Keep trigger foods out of the house. If it is not there, you cannot eat it at 10 pm.
- Eat protein at every meal. It keeps you fuller than anything else.
- Drink water, not calories.
- Cook in batches twice a week so fast food is not the easiest option.
- Read labels on things marketed as healthy, like granola, protein bars and flavored yogurt.
- Keep treats, but plan them instead of grazing on them.
Do I have to give up all processed food?
No. Frozen vegetables, canned beans, plain Greek yogurt and whole grain bread are processed and still good choices. Aim for most of your food to be minimally processed, not all of it. Read canned and frozen veggies: what to avoid and why ultra-processed foods will always be a problem.
If you want a plan built around your schedule and the food you actually like, take the XPL quiz.
Scroll to unlock levels
Level V Achieved
Now live it.
Unlocked
Frequently asked questions
What counts as ultra-processed food?
Foods made mostly from refined ingredients and additives, like soda, chips, candy, packaged pastries, instant noodles and most fast food.
Does it cost less to eat healthy?
Not always, but staples like rice, oats, beans, eggs, frozen vegetables and chicken thighs are affordable.
Why do I feel hungry after eating processed food?
Most are low in protein and fiber and digest fast, so fullness does not last. Written by Zavier King, personal trainer in Houston and online coach at XPL. ISSA Certified Personal Trainer and NASM Nutrition Coach. This article is general education, not medical advice.
Zavier King
Founder, XPERFORMANCELAB
I do not shape muscle. I shape structure. The person you become is the person you construct.
Related Insights
Gym or Home Workouts? Why I Train in the Gym and Still Keep Home Gear
Are gym workouts better than home workouts? The gym gives more tools to add load. Home training keeps you going when life gets busy. Use both.
Why Is My Face Aging Faster Than My Body?
Your face gets more sun than any other part of you, and UV is a main driver of skin aging. Daily sunscreen, sleep and not smoking help most.
What makes protein good for weight loss
This quick post will take aim at pointing out the benefits of making protein a key staple in your diet. There are low carb diets that...