4 Workout Myths: Deadlifts, Squats, “Toning” Reps and Machines
Deadlifts and squats are not bad for your back or knees when you use good form and sensible loads. Light weights for high reps do not firm up muscle in a special way, and machines are not automatically safer than free weights. These myths keep people away from the lifts that build the most strength.
Do deadlifts destroy your back?
No. Most back tweaks I see come from setup, not the lift itself:
- Rounding the spine before the bar leaves the floor
- Not knowing how to hip hinge
- Pulling with the arms instead of pushing the floor with the legs
- Using a belt instead of bracing, rather than in addition to it
Learn the hinge with a dowel or a Romanian deadlift first. Trap bar and sumo deadlifts are good options if a conventional pull feels awkward. If you have current back pain, see a doctor or physical therapist before loading it.
Do squats kill your knees?
No. Knees going past your toes is normal in a deep squat. Knee pain from squats usually comes from load jumps that are too big, knees caving inward, or depth your hips and ankles are not ready for yet. Work up gradually, keep your knees tracking over your toes, and use a box squat or goblet squat to find a depth that feels solid.
Do light weights and high reps “tone” muscle?
That firm look comes from building some muscle and losing enough fat for it to show. Light and heavy loads both build muscle when sets are taken close to failure (Schoenfeld et al., 2017). Heavy loads build more strength. The real myth is that lifting heavy makes women bulky. Read should women lift weights.
Are machines safer than free weights?
Not automatically. Machines are useful. They are easier to learn, good for isolating a muscle and handy when you are training alone. But they lock you into one path that may not fit your body, and they train less balance and stabilizer strength. Free weights done with good form are safe for most people. I use both with clients.
How do I train these lifts safely?
- Learn the pattern with light weight or bodyweight first.
- Add weight slowly, a small amount each week.
- Stop sets with one to three reps left in the tank on big lifts.
- Film yourself or work with a coach to check form.
- Rest and sleep enough to recover.
If you want a coach to teach you these lifts, take the XPL quiz, then see services.
Scroll to unlock levels
Level V Achieved
Now live it.
Unlocked
Frequently asked questions
Should I wear a lifting belt?
It can help on heavy sets once you know how to brace. It does not fix poor technique.
How deep should I squat?
As deep as you can with a neutral back and control. For most people that is thighs parallel or lower.
Can beginners deadlift?
Yes. Start with a light Romanian deadlift or trap bar deadlift and build up. Written by Zavier King, personal trainer in Houston and online coach at XPL. ISSA Certified Personal Trainer and NASM Nutrition Coach.
Zavier King
Founder, XPERFORMANCELAB
I do not shape muscle. I shape structure. The person you become is the person you construct.
Related Insights
Reasons why most personal trainers fail to create compelling content
How I Leverage Content Creation to Grow My Brand and Tips for Trainers By Zavier King What’s the word? I’m Zavier from xperformancelab,...
Self-care is not selfish
The problem with the term self-care I’m just going to come out and say it. So many narcissist cling to the term and it hurts the true...
This Is Marketing: You Can’t Be Seen Until You Learn To See by Seth Godin
Why read This is marketing This is marketing, is a timely and much needed up date because of social media. While its not hard to replace...