Am I Losing Fat or Muscle? How to Tell and How to Protect Muscle
If your strength is holding steady, your waist is shrinking and you are lifting two to three times a week with enough protein, most of what you are losing is fat. If your lifts are dropping fast, you feel flat and weak, and you are doing only cardio on low protein, you are likely losing a good share of muscle.
Why does it matter whether you lose fat or muscle?
Muscle is active tissue. It burns more energy at rest than fat does, even though the difference per pound is smaller than most people think (Wang et al., 2010). More important, muscle is what gives you shape, strength and the ability to keep weight off. If you diet down and lose a lot of muscle, you end up a smaller, softer version of where you started, and your maintenance calories drop.
Your basal metabolic rate, or BMR, is the energy you burn doing nothing at all. Losing muscle pulls that number down. Keeping it helps protect it.
What signs tell me I am losing fat?
- Your waist, hips and thighs are measuring smaller every few weeks.
- Your lifts are steady or still going up, or only slipping a little late in a long diet.
- Your clothes fit looser even when the scale is slow.
- Your progress photos look leaner, with more shape in the arms, shoulders and legs.
What signs tell me I am losing muscle?
- Your strength drops week after week, beyond the odd bad day.
- You look flat and smaller everywhere instead of leaner.
- You are losing more than about 1 percent of your body weight per week for a long stretch.
- You are not lifting at all, or doing only cardio classes.
- Your protein is low.
How do I protect muscle while losing fat?
Three things do most of the work.
- Lift weights two to three times a week at minimum. Focus on compound lifts like squats, deadlifts or hinges, presses, rows and pull-ups. Resistance training during a diet helps preserve lean mass compared to dieting alone or dieting with cardio only (Willis et al., 2012).
- Eat enough protein. Aim for about 1.6 grams per kilogram of body weight or more while dieting. In one trial, a higher protein group lost more fat and kept more lean mass in the same calorie deficit (Longland et al., 2016). See how to figure out your protein needs.
- Do not crash diet. A moderate deficit that drops 0.5 to 1 percent of your weight a week is easier to hold and kinder to muscle.
Cardio is still useful for heart health and burning extra calories. Do it alongside lifting, not instead of it.
How should I measure progress?
Use more than one measurement and check every three to four weeks:
- Body weight, taken the same way each time
- Waist and hip measurements with a tape
- Progress photos in the same light and pose
- A body fat scale, calipers or a DEXA scan if you have access
Home body fat scales have a real margin of error, so use them for trends, not single readings. Combined with photos and a tape measure, they still beat guessing. I explain my weighing routine in should I weigh myself daily.
If you want a plan that is built to keep your muscle while you cut, take the XPL quiz.
Scroll to unlock levels
Level V Achieved
Now live it.
Unlocked
Frequently asked questions
Does cardio burn muscle?
Cardio does not burn muscle by itself. Cardio with no lifting, low protein and a big deficit makes muscle loss much more likely.
Can you lose fat and gain muscle at the same time?
Yes, especially if you are new to lifting or coming back after a break. Read can you gain muscle without gaining fat.
Why is the scale stuck if I am losing fat?
Water, food in your gut and new muscle can hide fat loss for a week or two. Look at measurements and photos. Written by Zavier King, personal trainer in Houston and online coach at XPL. ISSA Certified Personal Trainer and NASM Nutrition Coach.
Zavier King
Founder, XPERFORMANCELAB
I do not shape muscle. I shape structure. The person you become is the person you construct.
Related Insights
Principles by Ray Dalio
Why should I read Principles by Ray Dalio Principles is written by Ray Dalio, who is considered the world’s most successful businessmen...
The Five Love Languages: Book review
A chapter-by-chapter breakdown of Gary Chapman's The Five Love Languages and how each language applies to communication, discipline and recovery.
Benefits of a Heart Rate Monitor, and Which Type to Buy
Is a heart rate monitor worth it? Yes, if you train by zones. Chest straps are the most accurate. Here is what I learned testing Polar and others.